Choice Architecture and Informed Consent in Public Health: Ethical Conditions for Community-Based Interventions

 

Saved in:
Bibliographic Details
Author: Ramos-Zaga, Fernando
Status:Versión publicada
Publication Date:2026
Description:The use of choice architecture in public health policy has renewed debate over the ethical legitimacy of interventions that shape shared decision environments without coercion but, because of their population-wide scope, preclude obtaining individual informed consent. Proposition: This article argues that the legitimacy of such interventions does not rest on formally preserving individual choice but on establishing institutional safeguards that protect autonomy through transparency, fairness, and democratic participation. Arguments for discussion: The analysis shows that the impossibility of obtaining individual informed consent does not diminish the obligation to protect autonomy. Instead, it requires replacing the protective function of consent with collective accountability mechanisms. Accordingly, a legitimacy framework is proposed based on transparency in intervention design, equitable distribution of benefits and burdens, prevention of structural stigma, and meaningful incorporation of the knowledge and perspectives of affected communities. The article also advances a deliberative governance model that integrates citizens' assemblies, independent bioethics review, proportionality, revisability, reversibility, collective objection mechanisms, and auditable design records. Conclusions: Choice architecture in public health can be considered ethically justifiable only when grounded in transparent, participatory, and accountable institutional procedures. Relational autonomy therefore provides a more appropriate normative framework than individual informed consent for evaluating interventions targeting populations and shared decision environments.
Country:Portal de Revistas UCR
Institution:Universidad de Costa Rica
Repositorio:Portal de Revistas UCR
Language:Español
OAI Identifier:oai:portal.revistas.ucr.ac.cr:article/1850
Online Access:https://revistas.ucr.ac.cr/index.php/rpsm/article/view/1850
Keyword:determinantes sociales de la salud
formulación de políticas
justicia social
participación de la comunidad
toma de decisiones
community participation
decision-making
policy making
social determinants of health
social justice